Home > Indian History > Indian Philosophy > Concept of Tarka
Concept of Tarka
Concept of Tarka as defined in Nyaya Philosophy is about the burden of proof and the role of presumption. It is further about the conditions under which even inconclusive evidence is sufficient for reasonable belief.

Share this Article:

Concept of Tarka, Nyaya PhilosophyConcept of Tarka in Nyaya Philosophy is well defined as the object of philosophical investigation. Further, in nyaya tradition, Tarka is considered as a technical term. Interestingly, different texts of Buddhist philosophy display a negative opinion of activities using tarka. On the contrary, some later treatises that are dealing with logical-epistemic problems especially the Naiyayika works recognise the methodological peculiarity of Nyaya traditions with tarka. Thus, philosophers believe that such an unsure attitude toward tarka can be easily understood in a logical way if its essential features can be grasped. Beginning from Nyaya Sutras as well as the explanations given in Nyaya Bhasya, three characteristic features of tarka has been sorted out in early Nyaya tradition. These three characteristic features of Nyaya Sutra focus on the principal feature of tarka that is reflective analysis of a subject or the on the object of investigation without calling for further factual information.

Suppositional reasoning or tarka is what gives knowledge of the universal generalisations grounding extrapolations. It has been mentioned in Nyaya philosophy that knowledge is achieved through the elimination of doubt, and what eliminates doubt is the existence of a compelling reason. But doubt is more infectious than it first appears, for one might doubt whether one`s reason really is compelling, doubt whether the reason for thinking that it is compelling is itself compelling, and so on forever along a familiar evidential regress. Doubts cascade, and truly compelling reasons are scarce. For analysing the role of reason in the management of doubt, later Nyaya epistemologists developed a theory of what they call `suppositional reasoning` or the concept of tarka. That the term tarka is used in this context is significant in itself. For in the basic and early literature, tarka is virtually synonymous with reasoned thinking in general. In its popular use, tarka or suppositional knowledge is the nearest one gets to a Sanskrit synonym for rationality.

Further, it is mentioned in Nyaya philosophy that suppositional reasoning or `tarka`, is a device for appropriating a presumptive right, the right to presume that one`s own position is correct even without conclusive evidence in its support. Following a doubt even if there is a desire to know the truth, the doubt still remains after the desire to know has come about. This is the situation intended for the application of suppositional reasoning. Thus, doubt is suppressed by the application of suppositional reasoning to its subject matter. A method of knowing is engaged to decide a question, but when there is a doubt involving its opposite, the method of knowing fails to engage. A radical sceptical hypothesis is a proposition inconsistent with ordinary belief, but consistent with all available evidence for it. Suppositional reasoning supports one`s means of acquiring evidence, but is not itself a source of evidence. Its role is pragmatic and situational; to change the standard of evidence required for proof in the specific context.


Share this Article:

Related Articles

More Articles in Indian Philosophy


Classical Indian Philosophy
Classical Indian Philosophy contains many analyses, rational principles and explanations. The Vedas have been considered as the first and the oldest scriptural texts of the Classical Indian Philosophy.
Ajivika Philosophy
Ajivika philosophy is different from the mainstream religion
Gunas - Hindu Philosophy
Guna in Hindu Philosophy in its philosophical sense refers to the constituent quality. The whole universe is guided by the three gunas, which are basically attitudes, qualities found in human being.
Bodhisattvas - Hindu Philosophy
Bodhisattva is a concept in Hindu philosophy and the Buddhist philosophy and refers to someone who is committed to attain Enlightenment.
Religion and Philosophy in Later Vedic Period
Religion and Philosophy in later Vedic period did see minute growth. However, rituals and traditions were religiously followed.
Theory of inference in Nyaya philosophy
Nyaya theory of inference is divided into five steps.
Theory for God in Nyaya philosophy
The Naiyayikas tried to establish the existence of God through logic.
Religious Influence on Indian Philosophy
Religious influence on Indian philosophy has been almost enigmatic, making it complimentary in perspective.
Morality and Ethics in Jain philosophy
Jains follow a fivefold path of morality and ethical purity, by which one can reach moksha.
Indian Philosophy In The Vedic Period
Indian Philosophy in the Vedic Period was primarily based on the concepts of nature worship.
Metaphysics in Jain philosophy
Metaphysics in Jain philosophy revolves heavily around the soul and its governing path and final emancipation.
Nether World in Jain Philosophy
Nether World according to Jain Cosmology consists of seven subterranean regions. Of the seven regions the above two regions serve as the abode of heavenly gods and in the rest torture of the souls is undertaken for any kind of misdeed.
Achintya Bheda Abheda Philosophy
Achintya-Bheda-Abheda is a School of Vedanta that represents the philosophy of unimaginable one-ness and difference in relation to the power creation and creator.